Although the quantitative trait locus (QTL) on chromosome 18 (BTA18) associated with paternal calving ease and stillbirth in Holstein Friesian cattle and its cross has been known for over 20 years, to our knowledge, the exact causal genetic sequence has yet escaped identification. The aim of this study was to re-examine the region of the published QTL on BTA18 and to investigate the possible reasons behind this elusiveness. For this purpose, we carried out a combined linkage disequilibrium and linkage analysis using genotyping data of 2,697 German Holstein Friesian (HF) animals and subsequent whole-genome sequencing (WGS) data analyses and genome assembly of HF samples. We confirmed the known QTL in the 95% confidence interval of 1.089 Mbp between 58.34 and 59.43 Mbp on BTA18. Additionally, these 4 SNPs in the near-perfect linkage disequilibrium with the QTL haplotype were identified: rs381577268 (on 57,816,137 bp, C/T), rs381878735 (on 59,574,329 bp, A/T), rs464221818 (on 59,329,176 bp, C/T), and rs472502785 (on 59,345,689 bp, T/C). Search for the causal mutation using short and long-read sequences, and methylation data of the BTA18 QTL region did not reveal any candidates though. The assembly showed problems in the region, as well as an abundance of segmental duplications within and around the region. Taking the QTL of BTA18 in Holstein cattle as an example, the data presented in this study comprehensively characterize the genomic features that could also be relevant for other such elusive QTL in various other cattle breeds and livestock species as well.